Judging My Own Book by Its Cover

Why Barking at Dogs went from a painting to a cartoon

We all know we shouldn't judge a book by its cover. We all do it anyway. I do it in every bookshop I walk into, and it turns out the people scrolling past my book on Amazon do it too.

When Barking at Dogs went out into the world on 30 September, it wore a cover I painted with a great deal of effort and care. I loved that cover and so did the people I showed it to. To me it looked the way the book feels, warm and a little rough round the edges.

The trouble is that a cover you love and a cover that sells books can turn out to be two different things, and sometimes we are simply too close to our projects to make the hard choices.

A postage stamp on a busy screen

Most people meet a book online first, and online a cover is about the size of a postage stamp. It sits in a row of other postage stamps, and somebody's thumb is moving fast. The cover gets about a second to make that thumb stop.

I'd been running a small Amazon ad campaign, and it showed me something I didn't want to see. The book wasn't converting the way I wanted it to. It may be creative work that lifts our spirits, but it's numbers that make the world go round. Plenty of reasons can sit behind disappointing numbers, but when I looked at the painted cover shrunk down to thumbnail size, I could see the problem that I had suspected would rear its ugly head. The detail I loved up close turned to mush. From a distance it didn't say much of anything.

The hard part

Changing it was easy enough. Deciding to change it took me a lot longer.

I wrote this book over six years of nights and weekends, and the cover was the first thing that made it feel real to me. Swapping it out felt a bit like admitting I'd got something wrong. Which, to be fair, I had.

What helped was remembering that once a book is out, it isn't really mine anymore. It belongs to whoever picks it up. The cover is the sign on the shop door, and its whole job is to get a stranger to come inside.

Going red

So, in November the book got a new cover, and it's red. It's bolder and funnier, and it reads at thumbnail size, which the old one never did. The new cover is hard to miss in a row of other books, and that's rather the point.

It's early days, and I'll be honest about how it goes. If the new cover doesn't move the needle either, you'll hear about that too.

And if you've already got a copy with the painted cover, hang on to it. When I am famous in certain circles, it’ll be a collectable. I'm still fond of the old cover even if the algorithm wasn't, but at least the painting is hanging in my living room to remind me to step back and see it as the buying public might.

Next
Next

The Friends Who Never Left